How to have ideas

On the one hand, much doctoral research is about careful analysis of what is already known, and exact, incremental, logical steps towards newer knowledge. On the other hand, the most interesting research is based on interesting ideas, innovative approaches, or impressive problem solving. 

Some people seem to have 10 ideas before breakfast, 9 of which wither before lunch–still leaving an inspiration every day (Reader, I married him). Other people tell me they aren’t creative, they don’t have ideas, or they often get stuck. 

So if you are starting on a new research project, wrestling with a difficult problem, or struggling to come up with an original contribution to knowledge, try these tips.

Some of them are things you should do regularly, others are things you might try as acute interventions to get things moving.

  1. Surround yourself with other people’s ideas. Read widely. Listen to podcasts. Watch documentaries. Go to exhibitions. Ideas in, ideas out.
  2. Get outside your field. Innovation happens in a thing called the zone of the adjacent possible. So you want enough knowledge widely dispersed to see the gaps between what you already know and what other people already know and to bridge those gaps or build out into those spaces.
  3. Have enough sleep/food/exercise/fresh air. Zombies have no ideas.
  4. double-alaskan-rainbow

  5. Take a ‘critical distance break’. This is what I call any time off that helps you to get away from your desk and return with a sharpened mind. Go for a ten minute walk, or take a nap, or have a bath, or wash the dishes, do a crossword or Sudoku puzzle, or sleep on it over night, or walk away from the desk for two weeks (depending on the size of the puzzle and how stuck you are.) This is a deliberate break, and I can’t tell you how often I have come back and gone ‘Oh I know the answer to that! That’s so obvious to me now!’ (Your subconscious has been mulling it over while you’ve been away and it works really well!)
  6. Don’t only type up research, or program, or do calculations. Use all the skills you have to explore ideas: write longhand in a journal, draw cartoons, make videos, dance your PhD, talk to friends down the pub. You may notice I bake bread to think about writing a lot! Sometimes using a ‘creative’ method to think about your area of expertise helps produce ‘creative’ answers.
  7. Keep a dream journal. Keep any kind of journal. Blogging also works! Reflecting and writing regularly is proven to help you have more ideas. Also, using your emotions, subconscious, or your dreams to problem solve is sometimes a way to make break throughs.
  8. Write every day. People who write everyday have more ideas and produce more than people who ‘wait to feel inspired’.
  9. Switch up your day. If you write best in the morning, spend some time problem solving in the evening with a glass of wine. If you think clearest in the afternoon, spend some time sketching out possibilities first thing in the morning before you’ve had coffee. (Research says you may be more creative when you are tired.)
  10. Have room for failed ideas. Give yourself an afternoon or an hour a week to try out possible ideas that may, or may not, work out. You can try out ideas by writing about them, experimenting with them, or exploring them with a friend or colleague. You are likely to have a lot of failures, but also more small successes than you might expect. And sometimes you might get a real breakthrough for truly original work !


10: An idea is great, but then you have to get back to the work of researching it, verifying it, testing it, workshopping it, writing it up. Ideas are only useful if they turn into something you can use in your thesis, teaching, publishing or further research.


And 11: Creative people have way more ideas than there is room for in a 3 year doctoral program! Work out which ideas are great, but belong in a later project– maybe your post doc, or an article you write after your PhD is finished. Work out which ideas are great but not right for you (start recommending these ideas to smart undergraduates and eventually recommend them to your doctoral supervision candidates).
Work out which ideas were fun to play with but will be stale or flat if you came back to them in a few hours, months or years time–these are fun brain bubbles, play with them while they are pretty and then let them rainbow wobble off into the sunset. There are plenty more ideas where they came from. 

Thanks to all the students and researchers who shared their experiences with me for this post. Do you have any techniques to prompt creative thinking that work for you? Let me know in the comments!


Succeeding in a Research Higher Degree

Doing a Research Higher Degree (like a PhD) is hard, but lots of people have succeeded and you can too. It’s easier if you understand how it works, this blog gives you the insider view.


Related Posts

What would it mean to make your writing sacred?

I don’t know that I think you should make your writing sacred. But I do think that you could and you might like to. In any case, this thought-experiment about ‘what would it mean to make your writing sacred’ may help you to think through what you do think about your writing, how you define its meaning and place in your life, and what habits and environments you put around it to help you get that thesis written.

Read More

Little writing luxuries

I am a massive fan of writing luxuries. Somehow the beautiful pencil or the diffuser scent or the ideal snack makes an outsized difference to how excited I am to sit at my keyboard. Maybe it’s a bourgeois trick, and maybe it’s self-care, and maybe it works for me and anything that works is worth exploring.

Read More

Get the latest blog posts